A Model of “ Integrated Scientific Method ” and its

A model of ‘integrated scientific method’ (ISM) was constructed as a framework for describing the process of science in terms of activities (formulating a research problem, and inventing and evaluating actions — such as selecting and inventing theories, evaluating theories, designing experiments, and doing experiments — intended to solve the problem) and evaluation criteria (empirical, conceptual, and cultural-personal). Instead of trying to define the scientific method, ISM is intended to serve as a flexible framework that — by varying the characteristics of its components, their integrated relationships, and their relative importance — can be used to describe a variety of scientific methods, and a variety of perspectives about what constitutes an accurate portrayal of scientific methods. This framework is outlined visually and verbally, followed by an elaboration of the framework and my own views about science, and an evaluation of whether ISM can serve as a relatively neutral framework for describing a wide range of science practices and science interpretations. ISM was used to analyze an innovative, guided inquiry classroom (taught by Susan Johnson, using Genetics Construction Kit software) in which students do simulated scientific research by solving classical genetics problems that require effect-to-cause reasoning and theory revision. The immediate goal of analysis was to examine the ‘science experiences’ of students, to determine how the ‘structure of instruction’ provides opportunities for these experiences. Another goal was to test and improve the descriptive and analytical utility of ISM. In developing ISM, a major objective was to make ISM educationally useful. A concluding discussion includes controversies about “the nature of science” and how to teach it, how instruction can expand opportunities for student experience, and how goal-oriented intentional learning (using ISM) might improve the learning, retention, and transfer of thinking skills. Potential educational applications of ISM could involve its use for instructional analysis or design, or for teaching students in the classroom; or ISM and IDM (a closely related, generalized ‘integrated design method’) could play valuable roles in a ‘wide spiral’ curriculum designed for the coordinated teaching of thinking skills, including creativity and critical thinking, across a wide range of subjects.